The start of baseball season means it’s time for predictions, but we asked our writers to take it a step further heading into Opening Day. The assignment was simple: Find two bets you would make for the 2019 MLB season, with one thing you are certain will happen and a long shot you think could pay off in a big way. Here’s what our baseball experts think will come true.
Feeling lucky? Jump to our long shot bets
Things you can bank on
Orioles under 59.5 wins
They have 38 games against two of baseball’s superpowers, the Red Sox and the Yankees, and the Rays could win 90-plus games as well. As the Orioles begin the process of rebuilding, they’ve done almost nothing to upgrade the lineup — what’s the point, after all — so why would they be 13 wins better than the 47-win team of 2018? A lock. — Buster Olney
There are always over-under win-total bets worth making. The Cubs and Rays over. The Giants and Blue Jays under. None is as sure a thing as the under on Baltimore at 59.5 wins. The Orioles are in a brutal division. They’re in active rebuild mode, so any valuable assets will be dealt. They might not be 47-115 bad again, but they won’t be much better. — Jeff Passan
Diamondbacks over 75.5 wins
They took some serious hits to last year’s 82-win team, but they should get credible starts from all five spots of the rotation. It’s hard to be that bad with an above-average rotation: FanGraphs’ projections have them at 79 wins, and Baseball Prospectus’ forecast is for 81, assuming there isn’t more midseason tearing down to come. — Sam Miller
Astros to win the American League West (-800)
The Astros won their division each of the past two years, and they are basically guaranteed to do so again. The Mariners and the Rangers are rebuilding, the A’s can’t possibly repeat what they did last year and the Angels don’t possess nearly as much talent. The Astros are crazy good. — Alden Gonzalez
Six months have passed and I’m still not sure how the A’s won 97 games. They’ll be good again, but not that good. And certainly not as good as Houston. — Eddie Matz
Brewers over 86.5 wins
Think the 2015 Royals or the 2016 Cubs. Milwaukee has unfinished business, like those teams had the previous seasons. And this isn’t even a World Series prediction — just that the Brewers won’t drop more than nine games off their 96-win total of last year. — Jesse Rogers
Reds under 78.5 wins
The Reds are going to be able to hit, but I’m not sure they have any chance at slowing down their opponents, which is a major issue in a loaded National League Central. I think they will struggle in that division in a big way this season, and if they are even close to repeating a league-worst 10-29 mark in one-run games, this under is a lock. — Kyle Soppe
Reds over 78.5 wins
The Reds were a bottom-half team in scoring runs and a bottom-third squad in preventing them last season. But the additions of Sonny Gray, Tanner Roark and Alex Wood should bring their pitching closer to the middle of the pack, while the offense should be improved with the acquisitions of Yasiel Puig and Matt Kemp as well as the expectation of a bounce-back year from Joey Votto, a full, healthy year from Jesse Winker and the promotion of prospect Nick Senzel. I would call the Reds one of the most improved teams of the offseason, and I think this is at worst a .500 squad. At best, it will sneak its way into the playoffs. — Tristan Cockcroft
Indians to win the American League Central (-400)
It’s not a big payout, but it’s hard to see a path for anyone to topple the Indians in the AL Central race. Some have gotten excited about the Twins. Don’t listen to those folks. Cleveland has a huge talent-plus-experience buffer against everyone else in that division, and it has a roster that should get better as the season progresses as the Indians fill some of the holes that they didn’t fill this winter. — Bradford Doolittle
Yasiel Puig over 24.5 home runs
Puig hit 23 home runs last season at Dodger Stadium in limited plate appearances (444). The year prior, in 570 plate appearances, Puig hit 28 long balls. Now Puig gets to hit in Great American Ball Park for half of his games and is projected to get roughly 600 plate appearances. He’s already hit four home runs in 32 at-bats in spring training. I think we are ultimately just fading a serious injury, so I grabbed the over. — Preston Johnson
Phillies to make the playoffs (+110)
The Phillies added more than Bryce Harper. The offense is remade, David Robertson settles the bullpen, the defense has improved and several of the young starting pitchers are about to blossom. This is a 90-win club bound to play games in October. — Eric Karabell
Nationals over 89 wins
Yes, predicting the NL East may feel like a fool’s errand, and the Nationals have a history of disappointing seasons (including last year). But they’re my pick to win the division, and I think they do it with 90-something wins. They lost Bryce Harper, but they’ll have a full season of Juan Soto plus Victor Robles to make up for the loss. Most importantly, they’ve fixed the big holes: catcher (Wilson Ramos and Kurt Suzuki), rotation depth (Patrick Corbin, Anibal Sanchez) and bullpen (Trevor Rosenthal, Kyle Barraclough). — David Schoenfield
Long shots that could pay off
Charlie Blackmon to win NL MVP (40-1)
The Rockies’ Blackmon is listed as 40-1 in the NL MVP race, behind 20 other possible contenders. Last season, Blackmon’s bWAR (0.8) was torpedoed by ugly defensive metrics and an uncharacteristic dip in BABIP. His move to an outfield corner could make Blackmon look like the league’s most improved player in his age-32 season, because he is minus-48 DRS for his career in center but plus-5 on the corners. That and replication of his 2017 offensive season — which is but a BABIP regression away — could propel Blackmon into the running. — Bradford Doolittle
Franmil Reyes to lead majors in home runs (200-1)
Reyes is a large man with big power, and he simply needs an opportunity to launch myriad home runs. Hunter Renfroe has the same odds, and it’s likely only one of them plays regularly; but Reyes hit a homer every 16 at-bats as a rookie, and no ballpark tames him. There is a chance for 40 big league blasts. — Eric Karabell
Juan Soto to win NL MVP and Ryan O’Hearn — who? — to be home run champ
Want a long shot that really could pay? Soto at 30-1 for NL MVP isn’t bad. Want a dark horse that could pay really well? Look at exit velocity, marry it with launch angle and you get Royals first baseman O’Hearn at 200-1 to be the home run champion. One other home run crown long shot: Rays outfielder Tommy Pham (500-1), who had a top-10 exit velo last season. — Jeff Passan
MVP voters are getting a lot smarter, and they’ll love it when Soto posts a .300/.450/.580 line with 100 runs and 100-something RBIs. He’s also made it an emphasis this spring to improve his defense (which will help his WAR, which will help his MVP case). Mike Trout and Alex Rodriguez were MVP runners-up in their age-20 seasons; Soto goes one spot higher. — David Schoenfield
Ronald Acuna Jr. to win NL MVP (25-1)
I have to wonder: Did the oddsmakers watch Acuna last year? Did they see the damage he did — 56 extra-base hits in 11 games? The OPS of 1.028 in the second half? The willingness early in his career to take a walk? At 25-to-1, that’s a great value bet. — Buster Olney
Acuna to be the home run king (60-1)
Does 60-1 count as a long shot? If so, then I’m all-in on Acuna Matater. Last April, a scout told me this about Acuna’s bombs: “As high and far as I’ve ever seen anybody hit ’em.” In the second half last season, when things started clicking for Acuna, he hit 19 homers in 68 games. Over a full season, that pace works out to 45 bombs, which is league-leader territory. — Eddie Matz
Rangers to win the wild-card game (250-1)
A super-young lineup that underperformed last year plus an old rotation of veterans whose careers were derailed by injuries means the Rangers are probably terrible. But one could imagine (if not count on) them getting 140 starts from the rotation and 85 bombs from Joey Gallo and Nomar Mazara. If it all works, maybe they will win 84 games, and maybe that’s enough in a league that has a massive drop-off after the top four teams. — Sam Miller
Yasiel Puig to win the NL MVP (40-1)
It’s a contract year for Puig, which means he’ll be motivated. He is one of a few stars on a bad team, which means he’ll play every day. He is hitting at Great American Ball Park, which means he’ll get his fair share of home runs. We might see something close to the Puig of 2013. — Alden Gonzalez
Wade Miley to lead the majors in wins (200-1)
First you might need to know that Miley is on the Astros, as his was the quintessential under-the-radar signing. His stuff is as good as ever, and he has a powerful offense to back him up. Remember, most wins has little to do with who the best pitcher is. Miley could pull this off. Think this is crazy? Charlie Morton went 15-3 for the Astros last season — Jesse Rogers
Patrick Corbin to lead the majors in wins (30-1)
There is some health risk here, and the division is certainly improved, but Corbin’s advanced metrics were even more impressive than his stellar 2018 numbers suggest, and I believe all Nationals prop bets hold some value given that the public is overreacting a bit to the impact of Harper’s departure. — Kyle Soppe
Giancarlo Stanton to lead the majors in home runs (+600)
This is something of a safe long shot, but Stanton hit .266 and 38 home runs in his “down” year as a Yankee in New York. Just one year prior, Stanton hit 59 in Marlins Park (ranked 29th of 30 in park runs factor; Yankee Stadium ranks sixth). My projections have him hitting 5.4 home runs more than any other batter, and Stanton has ranked top-eight in average exit velocity each season since Statcast started tracking it in 2015. Give me +600 he leads the majors again. — Preston Johnson
Chris Paddack to win NL Rookie of the Year (40-1)
Every year, there’s a favorite to win top rookie honors, and every year, something seems to go awry with that race. I know, I know, Victor Robles. But these are great odds for a pitcher who has an unusually low-risk skill set, including a 92-93 mph fastball and very good changeup, as well as pinpoint control of each. Paddack’s spring work has been electric. He is looking more likely to be in the Opening Day rotation than not. And let’s not forget that while Petco Park is no longer the pitchers’ heaven it once was, it is still a rather favorable environment for a pitcher to call home. — Tristan Cockcroft
More betting coverage: Season betting totals for all 30 teams (ESPN+)